| M | 1-10 | M27 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| M | 1-10 | M27 | HAM ball on HAM30. |
| | | Garrett Hoy kickoff 59 yards to the MID11, B. Rankowitz return 26 yards to the MID37 (Ted Finan). |
| M | 1-10 | M37 | MIDDLEBURY drive start at 14:51 (3rd). |
| M | 1-10 | M37 | R. Ashkar rush right for 8 yards to the MID45 (Dan Peters). |
| M | 2-2 | M45 | R. Ashkar rush up middle for 5 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN MID (C. Bueneman). |
| M | 1-10 | M50 | M. Foote middle pass intercepted by Dan Peters at the HAM28, Dan Peters return 38 yards to the MID34 (Z. Driscoll;R. Moores). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 13 yards, TOP 01:02 |
| V | 1-10 | M34 | HAMILTON drive start at 13:49 (3rd). |
| V | 1-10 | M34 | Jordan Eck rush right for 5 yards to the MID29, out-of-bounds (Z. Faber). |
| V | 2-5 | M29 | Jordan Eck middle pass complete to Kevin Petrick for 23 yards to the MID6, 1ST DOWN HAM (J. Onouye). |
| V | 1-G | M06 | James Stanell rush up middle for 2 yards to the MID4 (M. Rea;Z. Faber). |
| V | 2-G | M04 | James Stanell rush right for 2 yards to the MID2 (M. Cawley). |
| V | 3-G | M02 | James Stanell rush up middle for 1 yard to the MID1 (K. Ashley;B. Adams). |
| V | 4-G | M01 | James Stanell rush up middle for 1 yard to the MID0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:23. |
| | | Garrett Hoy kick attempt good. |
| | | Middlebury 20, Hamilton 14 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 34 yards, TOP 03:26 |
| | | Garrett Hoy kickoff 53 yards to the MID17, B. Rankowitz return 22 yards to the MID39 (Kal Campbell). |
| M | 1-10 | M39 | MIDDLEBURY drive start at 10:16 (3rd). |
| M | 1-10 | M39 | R. Ashkar rush up middle for 4 yards to the MID43 (Mike MacDonald). |
| M | 2-6 | M43 | M. Foote left pass complete to M. Wassel for 10 yards to the HAM47, 1ST DOWN MID (Dylan Isenberg). |
| M | 1-10 | V47 | M. Foote right pass complete to N. Resor for loss of 2 yards to the HAM49 (Ted Finan). |
| M | 2-12 | V49 | R. Ashkar rush up middle for 8 yards to the HAM41 (Jared Kochenash;Dan Peters). |
| M | 3-4 | V41 | M. Foote middle pass complete to M. Wassel for 6 yards to the HAM35, 1ST DOWN MID (Austin Durham). |
| M | 1-10 | V35 | R. Ashkar rush up middle for 5 yards to the HAM30 (Camron Waugh). |
| M | 2-5 | V30 | M. Foote right pass incomplete to Z. Driscoll, PENALTY HAM pass interference 15 yards to the HAM15, 1ST DOWN MID, NO PLAY. |
| M | 1-10 | V15 | M. Foote middle pass incomplete to R. Ashkar. |
| M | 2-10 | V15 | M. Foote right pass incomplete to N. Resor, PENALTY HAM pass interference 13 yards to the HAM2, 1ST DOWN MID, NO PLAY. |
| M | 1-G | V02 | R. Ashkar rush left for 2 yards to the HAM0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 07:25. |
| | | D. Miller kick attempt good. |
| | | Middlebury 27, Hamilton 14 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 61 yards, TOP 02:51 |
| | | D. Miller kickoff 49 yards to the HAM21, John Fisher return 21 yards to the HAM42 (N. Burdeau). |
| V | 1-10 | V42 | HAMILTON drive start at 07:18 (3rd). |
| V | 1-10 | V42 | Jordan Eck middle pass complete to Garrett Hoy for 11 yards to the MID47, 1ST DOWN HAM (J. Onouye). |
| V | 1-10 | M47 | Jordan Eck right pass complete to James Stanell for 1 yard to the MID46 (A. Donnelly). |
| V | 2-9 | M46 | Jordan Eck left pass complete to Ryan Cray for 3 yards to the MID43 (J. Blockowicz). |
| V | 3-6 | M43 | Jordan Eck left pass complete to James Stanell for 2 yards to the MID41 (D. Kenerson). |
| V | 4-4 | M41 | Jordan Eck pass incomplete (K. Ashley). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 17 yards, TOP 01:46 |
| M | 1-10 | M41 | MIDDLEBURY drive start at 05:32 (3rd). |
| M | 1-10 | M41 | M. Foote screen pass complete to R. Ashkar for 16 yards to the HAM43, 1ST DOWN MID (Ted Finan). |
| M | 1-10 | V43 | R. Ashkar rush up middle for 5 yards to the HAM38 (Camron Waugh;Mike MacDonald). |
| M | 2-5 | V38 | M. Foote right pass complete to R. Ashkar for 20 yards to the HAM18, 1ST DOWN MID (Ted Finan). |
| M | 1-10 | V18 | R. Ashkar rush up middle for 8 yards to the HAM10 (Dan Peters). |
| M | 2-2 | V10 | R. Ashkar rush up middle for 1 yard to the HAM9 (M. De Percin). |
| M | 3-1 | V09 | R. Ashkar rush up middle for 2 yards to the HAM7, 1ST DOWN MID (Camron Waugh). |
| M | 1-G | V07 | R. Ashkar rush up middle for loss of 1 yard to the HAM8 (Camron Waugh). |
| M | 2-G | V08 | M. Foote middle pass incomplete to N. Resor. |
| M | 3-G | V08 | M. Foote middle pass complete to B. Chapman for 8 yards to the HAM0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:31. |
| | | D. Miller kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by Mike MacDonald) (Mike MacDonald). |
| | | Middlebury 33, Hamilton 14 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 59 yards, TOP 03:01 |
| | | D. Miller kickoff 40 yards to the HAM30, John Fisher return 18 yards to the HAM48 (Z. Faber;D. Miller). |
| V | 1-10 | V48 | HAMILTON drive start at 02:23 (3rd). |
| V | 1-10 | V48 | Jordan Eck left pass complete to Garrett Hoy for 6 yards to the MID46 (J. Blockowicz). |
| V | 2-4 | M46 | Jordan Eck right pass incomplete to M. Shriver (M. Bilodeau). |
| V | 3-4 | M46 | Jordan Eck middle pass incomplete to Kevin Petrick (J. Pesce). |
| V | 4-4 | M46 | PENALTY MID offside 5 yards to the MID41, 1ST DOWN HAM. |
| V | 1-10 | M41 | Jordan Eck pass incomplete. |
| V | 2-10 | M41 | James Stanell rush left for 9 yards to the MID32, out-of-bounds (M. Bilodeau). |
| V | 3-1 | M32 | PENALTY HAM false start 5 yards to the MID37. |